Mar 6 Podcast #1243: Set Top Box Shootout
On this week’s show we have a shootout between four set top boxes and we try to determine which one is best for you. We also read your email and take a look at the week’s email.
| Download this Episode. |
Support the show with Patreon!
Listen to the show
Today's Show:
News:
- Netflix Walks With A Cool $2.8 Billion Breakup Fee: Who Gets What In New Paramount-WBD Merger Proposal
- Viewers Continue To 'Struggle' With Sports Program Discovery
- Samsung Wallet's 'Digital Home Key' lets me use my phone to open my doors
Other:
- HT Guys Amazon Lists
- HT Guys Music Playlist on Apple Music
- HT Guys Music Playlist on Amazon Music
- HT Guys Music Playlist on Spotify
- Ara's Woodworking
Set Top Box Shootout
On last week’s show, in response to a news story, Ara asked why would someone use a FireTV set top box over ones from Apple, Google, or Roku. So for this week we decided to do a comparison of them all and try to identify who each product would benefit the most.
For this comparison we looked at the Apple TV 4K (latest 3rd-gen model from 2022, still current), Google TV Streamer (the modern successor to Chromecast with Google TV), Roku (focusing on high-end like Roku Ultra or Streaming Stick 4K), and Amazon Fire TV (focusing on popular models like Fire TV Stick 4K Max or Cube).
All support 4K HDR streaming including Dolby Vision, major apps (Netflix, Disney+, etc.), and voice remotes. In a nutshell, the differences come down to your ecosystem, interface, performance, ads, and price.
Apple TV 4K
- Price range: ~$129–$149 (64GB Wi-Fi or 128GB Wi-Fi + Ethernet).
- Key specs: A15 Bionic chip (fast/smooth), Wi-Fi 6, optional Ethernet, Dolby Vision/Atmos/HDR10+, Thread smart home hub, USB-C Siri Remote.
Pros:
- Premium, ad-free high performance interface with fast app loading.
- Excellent integration with Apple ecosystem (iPhone, iPad, Mac, AirPlay, Apple TV+, Fitness+, Arcade).
- Superior picture/audio quality, privacy focus (less tracking), and acts as a smart home hub.
- Great for gaming (Apple Arcade) and high-end home theater setups.
Cons:
- Most expensive option.
- Less neutral—prioritizes Apple content/services.
- Fewer "free/ad-supported" channels compared to rivals.
Best for: Apple users and those wanting a premium, ad free experience.
Google TV Streamer
- Price range: ~$90–$100 (Buy Now).
- Key specs: Powerful processor (faster than old Chromecast), 32GB storage, Wi-Fi 6, Ethernet, Dolby Vision/Atmos, Google Home/Matter smart home support, hands-free options in some setups.
Pros:
- Intuitive, personalized interface with excellent content discovery/search across services.
- Strong Google ecosystem integration (YouTube, Nest, Google Assistant, synced watchlists).
- Good performance/speed, supports cloud gaming, and broad app support.
- Balanced neutral approach.
Cons:
- Some ads and recommendations can feel cluttered.
- More expensive than basic sticks but cheaper than Apple.
- Interface may prioritize Google content slightly.
Best for: Google/Android users or those wanting smart recommendations and smart home features.
Roku (Ultra or Streaming Stick 4K)
- Price range: ~$30–$100 (Buy Now).
- Key specs: Fast quad-core processor (in Ultra), Wi-Fi 6, Ethernet (Ultra), Dolby Vision/Atmos/HDR10+, rechargeable Voice Remote Pro (Ultra), broad smart home compatibility.
Pros:
- Simple, neutral, user-friendly interface with huge app/channel selection (including tons of free/ad-supported content).
- No heavy ecosystem bias—treats all services equally.
- Often the most affordable high-quality options; great search/universal watchlist.
- Compatible with Alexa, Google, Apple Home; highly popular among cord-cutters.
Cons:
- Can feel slower on lower-end models compared to premium rivals.
- Some ads on home screen.
- Less "smart home hub" depth than Apple/Google.
Best for: Most people—especially beginners or those wanting value and neutrality.
Amazon Fire TV (Fire TV Stick 4K Max or Cube)
- Price range: ~$25–$60 Sticks (Buy Now) to ~$100+ Cube (Buy Now).
- Key specs: Fast processor/Wi-Fi 6E (Max), Dolby Vision/Atmos, Alexa voice, Ambience mode, Ethernet (Cube).
Pros:
- Very affordable, especially on sale.
- Quick performance and deep Amazon Prime integration (Prime Video priority).
- Excellent Alexa/smart home control (Ring, Echo, etc.).
- Good app support and features like live TV guides.
Cons:
- Heavy ads and Prime content promotion (can feel pushy/cluttered).
- Interface prioritizes Amazon ecosystem over neutrality.
- Privacy concerns with more tracking.
Best for: Amazon Prime members or Alexa/Echo households on a budget.
Overall, Roku wins for broad appeal and value, while we give the nod to the Apple TV 4K for premium quality, and the Google TV Streamer excels for smart features. Choose based on your ecosystem (Apple/Google/Amazon) or if you want neutral/no-fuss just go with Roku.
Reader Comments (1)
I rate the streamers as such:
1. Fire TV Stick 4K Max
2. Google TV
3. Apple TV
4. Roku TV
I have two Fire TV Sticks and 3 Google TV dongles. I prefer the Fire TV Stick remote because most of the buttons aren't doing double duty. Also, the tiles don't move around when scrolling like they do with the Google TV. Roku TV gets the lowest rating because it seems most of the complaints about HDHOMERUN on Reddit are from Roku TV users. I also use the app to watch 1 show. You would think if it had any smarts it would pick that when I do a search.